Audiokinetic's Community Q&A is the forum where users can ask and answer questions within the Wwise and Strata communities. If you would like to get an answer from Audiokinetic's Technical support team, make sure you use the Support Tickets page.

Clipping produces pops instead of expected distortion

0 votes

I just started testing moving a project from FMOD to Wwise and immediately ran into some annoying behavior.  I opened a new and empty project in Wwise with default settings and changed nothing else as far as I know.  Yet, all samples with clipping -- like the one pictured below -- play with a pop at each clipping point instead of just the usual distortion (distortion I don't mind and even want).  What gives?  FMOD has surprisingly incomplete Unity integration -- prompting a move to a new tool... but this, on the other hand, is just really dumbfounding.  It makes me wonder if I'm missing something obvious, or is it that Wwise just wasn't meant to handle distortion like this?  But, that just sounds too stupid to say so I must be missing something.

I've tried dumping the samples and re-importing them.  Same results.  Samples that don't clip play fine.  All samples that clip play with pops.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/q5z5y6lk89suskn/On-0883rpm-4cyl.wav?dl=0

in General Discussion by Matt J. (350 points)
edited by Matt J.
Can you post one of your sample somewhere so we can have a look?
by Bernard R. (Audiokinetic) (35.8k points)
Hello Matt, can you upload and post a link to one of the wavs that is causing the issue in your project ? thanks !
by Fabien B. (Audiokinetic) (12.9k points)
moved by Bernard R. (Audiokinetic)
I updated the question with a link to the wav and tried again to add the image.
by Matt J. (350 points)

1 Answer

+1 vote
 
Best answer

Thanks Matt. We were able to reproduce. We will take a look. It appears the WAV file contains samples outside the valid range.
Do you know which software was used to generate this WAV file?

Please note that this will not occur in the game. If you convert the file (using Convert... in Wwise ) then uncheck the Orignal button in the transport, you will notice the click disappear.

by Bernard R. (Audiokinetic) (35.8k points)
selected by Matt J.
Glad to know you can reproduce and it wasn't just me.  The WAV was last exported from an Audacity 2.1.3 project.  The last effect applied to it was Amplify with clipping allowed (obviously).  I believe that was to normalize power.  I'll look into Convert and see how I feel about how it affects workflow.
by Matt J. (350 points)
Any update on this?  Is it expected to be fixed?  I have found the "Convert" workaround to be acceptable but it is still more than a little concerning that an audio tool can't play many of my samples the same as in-game without an extra step (more than just the engine audio).
by Matt J. (350 points)
The issue (WG-40566) was scheduled for a point release update.
by Bernard R. (Audiokinetic) (35.8k points)
Powered by Question2Answer
...